The 5 Myths of Facebook Promoted Posts

The Facebook Promoted Posts feature is the simplest way to start an online advertising campaign anywhere. Hands down.

Click “Promote.” Click “Save.” Campaign starts…

Sure, if you’re a first time advertiser you’ll need to enter a billing method. And you can adjust your budget and whether you’re targeting Fans or Fans and Friends of Fans.

But man. That’s easy!

Because it’s so easy, it’s incredibly tempting to promote nearly every post I write. The Reach screams at me immediately after publishing. It’s no coincidence that this statistic is right… next… to the Promote button.

So it’s easy. Almost too easy. And I’ve gotten great results from Promoted Posts. But I know that many of you still need to be sold. In fact, you’ve already been sold something, and that’s a bag of lies.

There are several myths about Facebook Promoted Posts that are making their rounds, likely started by people who don’t know what they’re talking about. Don’t perpetuate these myths. Educate!

1) “I don’t have the budget.”

Some people are bound and determined never to give Facebook a single dime of their money. Others are convinced that the cost to make any sort of difference isn’t in their budget.

This is simply not true.

Look. I’m one cheap dude. I hate spending money. I am a small business owner. An entrepreneur. I have struggled fast and I have struggled hard. I’ve been at this for one year, trying to support a family of five.

In the beginning, I refused to spend money. But eventually, I realized what all of the successful people have long told us to be true: You’ve gotta spend money to make money.

And I don’t mean spending a fortune. I don’t mean throwing hundred dollar bills around and making it rain. I’m talking about spending as little as $1 at a time.

One. Dollar.

Most people don’t realize this is possible. When you start a promotion, you can choose options of $5, $10, $15 and on up, depending on the size of your Page. But you can stop that promotion at any time.

Just click the Promoted button and then the drop-down on the left to get the option to stop your promotion.

Here’s a recent example when I did this. I wrote a blog post about the 27 WordPress plugins I use. It’s admittedly a little off topic since I focus mainly on Facebook marketing. The Reach out of the gate was awful, and I ended up only reaching 801 people without advertising. That’s poor for my posts.

So I wanted to give it a little boost and promoted it for $.96 and reached 581 more people while getting an additional seven links clicks.

Seven link clicks not a big deal? Maybe. But considering the blog post had affiliate links in it, every click has value.

Since this is the type of post I would promote with Google AdWords, I’d consider $.14 per click to be pretty freaking good.

I’ve heard complaints that the cost is higher per impression when using Promoted Posts. Sure, this is true. But look beyond that.

I’ve seen the impact that a single dollar can make. Understand that your audience is qualified and extremely targeted. You know they dig your stuff. So you’ll find quite a bit of success by reaching a few more people who wouldn’t have otherwise seen your post.

2) “I shouldn’t have to pay to reach all of my Fans!”

Oh, man. When people say this, I just shake my head (I’ve written about this topic before). I know they are going to be a difficult sell. But let me do my best…

First, understand that Facebook and its EdgeRank algorithm aren’t the main reason you aren’t reaching all of your Fans. The main reason is that they simply aren’t online when you post. Only half of your Fans are on Facebook on a given day, and the average amount of time is 30 minutes.

Facebook Fans are a moving target. You expect to reach 100% of them? Well, how about your email list? That is a stationary target, yet you only get an average open rate of 20%. You expect to do significantly better than that?

Anyway, it’s a hot topic for me. But that’s my first rebuttal. Paying for Promoted Posts simply helps you reach more people who weren’t online when you posted. When they are on, this will slide to the top, even if you published your content three days ago.

Second, a major misconception is that Facebook keeps it so that only 16% of your Fans see your content, “forcing” you to pay for advertising to reach the rest. The truth is that advertising won’t help you reach the rest. In fact, I’ve found that even when I advertise I’m unable to reach more than 35% of my Fans.

Promoted Posts won’t assure you of reaching everyone. There is no way to guarantee that. But you can reach more. Given how difficult it is to reach your Fans (for numerous reasons), this is a fantastic tool.

3) “I already reach a high percentage of my Fans, so I don’t need it.”

You’re rocking your Facebook marketing. You’ve never advertised and your Fan base is qualified and strong. You reach, on average, 35% of your Fans every time you publish.

Alright, smart guy, you’re pretty awesome. But you know what? Promoted Posts can still help you. A lot.

Not only will Promoted Posts help you reach those Fans your awesome marketing skills somehow missed, but you can also reach Friends of Fans. When you click that Promote button, you’ll have the option of targeting only your Fans or both your Friends and their friends.

That’s some powerful stuff. People are more likely to buy a product or engage with a brand if it’s been endorsed by a friend. So by casting your net a little wider, you are increasing the possibility for growth.

4) “I don’t need it to reach my goals.”

You just use good old fashioned hard work. That’s to be commended. But just know… By refusing to spend just a few dollars, you are missing some significant opportunities.

You could reach your goals without Promoted Posts. But you can set the bar higher by making a very small investment in Facebook Promoted Posts.

Let me provide an example…

I published a post a week ago that was a review of the Genesis Framework, a WordPress theme. I use Genesis, and I am also an affiliate. So when people go to that review, click my link to Genesis and make a purchase, I get a cut of that.

Without promotion, this post received nine link clicks to my review. I then paid $5 and received 22 more, more than tripling the amount of views of that blog post (from nine to 31). So I spent $5 to get 22 clicks for a CPC of $.23.

Let’s put that into perspective. I also ran a Google AdWords promotion that drove people to that same blog post using a search ad. I spent $17.62 to get nine clicks for a CPC of $1.96 with AdWords.

Did I need to do this? Nope. I could have continued to promote the way I typically do and hope people click and eventually buy. But by promoting my post, I reached more people, more people clicked the link, more people then clicked my affiliate link and I then received revenue I would not have otherwise received (well over the $5 cost of the ad).

5) “It doesn’t work.”

Simply. Not. True.

I’ve shown some of my results already. But let’s provide another one for the skeptics.

My results are small potatoes when compared to an example provided by my friend, John Haydon.

John spent $14.62 to reach 21,612 more people, get 836 more comments, 119 more Page post Likes, 77 more link clicks, 35 more Page post shares and 10 Page Likes. All on one post!

That’s insane!

You won’t get these kinds of results every time you promote a post (if ever). But the value is there for the taking. You just need to be strategic!

Closing Thoughts

Before I go (thank you, Amy, for allowing me this space!), I just want to make one more thing clear. While I love Promoted Posts and think they are a great tool, you should be smart about what you promote.

Not everything is “promotion-worthy.” Spend money on posts that will lead to direct or indirect income that you can track. Or at minimum, promote posts that help lead you to a business goal.

For example, as a blogger one of my goals is to write viral content. When I write viral content, I get more page views. When I get more page views, I get more ad and affiliate revenue as well as more clients (assuming the traffic is qualified).

So in some cases, I will promote a post that I believe in with hopes of helping push it to the next level of virality. But also feel free to promote anything that drives direct revenue, subscriptions or downloads.

What types of content are you promoting with Promoted Posts?

About Jon Loomer

Jon Loomer is a solopreneur with more than five years of
experience in Facebook marketing. Beginning one year ago, he put that
experience to the test by starting his own business as a Facebook
Marketing Coach, blogger and consultant. Read his tips at JonLoomer.com or Like his Facebook Page to learn more about how you can build trust, build a business, build a brand and make a difference with Facebook marketing.

  • https://www.facebook.com/VladimirByazrov Vladimir Byazrov

    Sometimes I get zero result from promotions. no extra likes and comments, but the ad manager says I had few thousand more views. It’s seems like a lie to me, but I still haven’t lost all hope in this product.

  • http://jonloomer.com/blog Jon Loomer

    Vladimir — Keep in mind that if you are promoting to Fans + Friends of Fans with your Promoted Posts, you’re bound to get less interaction per view than if only Fans see it. That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t target Friends of Fans (I do), just something to remember.

    Promoted Posts also seem to work best when they have already received some natural interaction. In other words, people will engage when others already have (social proof). And if you have a post that was bound to get low engagement, promotion won’t help. I know I’ve done it!

    Glad to hear you aren’t giving up, though. Thanks for your feedback!

  • https://www.facebook.com/VladimirByazrov Vladimir Byazrov

    thanks, Jon! I think I am using all powers of that service. Hopefully it will pay back with more people engaged in conversations.

  • http://www.stevefogg.com Steve Fogg

    Jon,

    I LOVE promoted posts and have seen over the last month a 2000% increase (no, its not a typo) in the reach of the Facebook page I manage. I’ve also seen around a 30% increase in new likes too. Interactions and shares are off the charts too.

    The increase of reach is from around 3,500 > 85,000.

    I wrote on my blog about what I think are the key ingredients over and above the budget as I think that is just as an important part of the mix too. I’d drop a link, but I don’t like spamming comments, just check out my twitter feed if anyone is interested.

    While the page is for a non-profit (The church I’m the Comm’s Director at) It is slamming the goals that I want from our Facebook page. And dirt cheap.

  • http://antoniocalero.com/ Antonio Calero

    Excelent post John, very useful. I have never hesitated to propose this option to some clients and most of the times I’ve heard many of the responses you wrote. However my response use to be more assertive: “you want to play the Facebook game? Then you must accept their rules” If you don’t like them, then you should use other platform…

    Your article provides a more detailed explanation of why this is a good option. In fact, the only reason why I’m not using it for my own profile is because I still have not reached the minimum 400 followers to have this option available.

  • http://justicewordlaw.com/ Justice Wordlaw IV

    Really great blog post Jon. I’ve seen the advantages of running Facebook promoted posts and what you recommend above is all so true and correct.

  • sunny617

    Thanks for the article!

    I’ve done a promoted post twice. The one thing that bothers me is that you can’t target like you can with regular ads.

    The second time I selected “just people who like the page” and that worked fine. However, the first time, I selected “people who like your page and their friends.” I was thrilled when I saw huge, explosive numbers, even some comments. But it turned out, many of those viewers had nothing to do with my client’s B2B industry. Many were from foreign countries and commented in a foreign language. There was no visible connection to my client’s industry. Now, people might think “Why is she complaining…likes are likes!” but that’s just not the case here. My client doesn’t want huge numbers of random people, he, rightfully so, wants to see how Facebook is reaching his customers or potential customers.

    A similar thing happened when I ran regular Facebook ads. Even with heavy targeting, I got a lot of likes from people that have no connection to my industry. Based on the fact that many of them have fanned thousands of brand pages, I call them “serial likers.”

    Any idea why this happened? Has anyone else had similar experiences?

  • http://jonloomer.com/blog Jon Loomer

    Thanks for the comment, Sunny!

    You bet, I agree with you completely on quality > quantity. When you target Fans + Friends of Fans you are at the mercy of the quality of your Fans’ friends. The larger your Fan base, the more likely that there will be some of that riffraff. So, sure, if you target just your Fans, you’re more likely to get quality engagement. If you expand the net, you may get more less quality engagement. But you also increase the possibility of reaching quality people who didn’t know of you before. It’s a balance.

    When you run standard ads to get Likes, I highly recommend not using Optimized CPM. This is the only way to run these ads through Ad Manager, but if you use Power Editor you can use CPM or CPC (I tend to prefer CPM). The problem with Optimized CPM goes to the core of why they are effective: Facebook targets your ad at people most likely to perform the desired action. In many cases, this ends up being spam, bot or undesirable accounts.

    So the first recommendation would be to avoid Optimized ads. The second would be to focus your ads in the US or countries where you are not seeing a high concentration of these questionable accounts.

    Hope this helps!

  • http://jonloomer.com/blog Jon Loomer

    Thanks, Justice!

  • http://jonloomer.com/blog Jon Loomer

    Good call, Antonio! I agree with you completely. I see that explanation as the fallback. I don’t believe that reach is limited in an effort to force you to buy ads (which would lead to “playing by their rules”). But that said, many people are going to believe this no matter what. And if I can’t get them to believe it, well… play by the rules, play the game or get off of Facebook!

    Whether it’s a game or not, there’s value. I guess that’s the most important thing!

    Really appreciate your comment, Antonio.

  • http://jonloomer.com/blog Jon Loomer

    I believe it, Steve! Even though I’ve largely seen only moderate success compared to some like you and John in my example, it’s still success. The key seems to be to promote posts that are already begging for engagement. Promoting them multiplies the virality. Promoting posts that aren’t good bait for engagement won’t get you nearly as far.

    It’s common sense, really, but important to remember that Promoted Posts aren’t a magic bullet to make boring posts go viral.

    Awesome results, though, Steve. Thanks for the info!

  • sunny617

    Thanks very much for taking the time to respond! I’ll give your recommendations a shot!

  • http://jonloomer.com/blog Jon Loomer

    Let me know how it goes, if you can. Good luck!

  • http://www.facebook.com/imdara Dara Drea O’Neill

    Great article, as Facebook say themselves – they never changed the reach of fan pages, they simply added a function if you want to improve it. For some extra clams of course.

    I have one burning question though, perhaps you can help. If I target my post to a certain city and a certain age group Facebook gives me a number e.g. ‘Targeted to: 3000′

    Is this then the number I should be paid promoting to? Am I wasting money trying to spend $50 reaching 20,000 people?

  • http://brittandersonphotography.com/ Britt Anderson

    Fabulous post…and like you, I shake my head every time someone mentions #2. I think I may start working the paid promotions!

  • http://jonloomer.com/blog Jon Loomer

    Thanks, Britt! It’s simply an issue of a lack of education — not only of the typical user, but the media. I’ve seen this myth perpetuated more times than I care to count.

    Thanks for your comment!

  • http://jonloomer.com/blog Jon Loomer

    Thanks, Dara! You’re absolutely right.

    Regarding your question, I can’t imagine you’d hit your target. Promoted Posts are different than their other forms of advertising since they only hit the same Fan or Friend of Fan once. Others don’t have a cap on frequency.

    I will say that I’ve never promoted a post that I had previously targeted. I’d experiment with it on a very small scale. I assume that Facebook carries over that targeting to their promotion, but I would not be surprised if that’s not the case. Keep in mind that the post targeting is not absolute — it’s only News Feed. So while you target only women from Canada in your post, anyone could see it if they came to your Timeline. I just wonder if this matters in a Promoted Post.

    In other words, I don’t have a definite answer for you, but worth experimenting!

  • Janet – Mum the Photographer

    Hi there, Can I target my audience with a promoted post. My business is aimed at parents and while I’ve achieved lots of “likes” from promoted posts I am not correctly reaching my target audience. Thanks for any advice,
    Janet – Mum the Photographer

  • http://jonloomer.com/blog Jon Loomer

    Janet — Promoted Posts can be targeted at either your Fans or your Fans + their friends. So if your target audience is your Fans, you should be fine!

  • http://www.facebook.com/brenda.deskin Brenda Kosky Deskin

    Question- can viewers of your page see whether a post is promoted or not?

  • http://www.AmyPorterfield.com Amy Porterfield

    They will see the word “sponsored” in the lower right corner of the post- really small though :-)

  • Bjorn Karlman

    Well, you’ve sold me on the idea that Facebook Promoted Posts work… should it on a blog that I am not planning on monetizing right now? Or should I only use it in cases where there would be clear, monetary ROI?

  • http://jonloomer.com/blog Jon Loomer

    Bjorn — It depends on your goals and expectations. If your goal is to make direct income on a site you aren’t currently monetizing, then no. It won’t help you. But if your goal early is to build an engaged audience, then use it.

    I haven’t only used Promoted Posts for driving direct revenue. There are times when I simply have the goal of reaching more people with a post that I feel is important or has the potential to go viral. You just need to have your goals for that promotion established ahead of time.

    Thanks, Bjorn!

  • http://www.facebook.com/sjordancircwiz Stuart Jordan

    Excellent post! Completely mirrors my recent experience.

  • http://www.theworkingbee.com/ Michael Belk

    Jon it is worth trying. I do not have anything to lose. thanks for explaining it so well.

  • Katie

    I have seen so many comments recently where people are getting huge engagement from promoted posts – but all are from foreign accounts (India, Malaysia, Thailand) and these businesses promoting are in NZ or Australia and many hold little or no interest to anyone out of the country – or are pages for women/children and all the new likers/comments are from foreign men, and what appears to be false accounts. This is really worrying and makes you wonder why/how is the page being promoted – there has been alot of talk with Facebook buying fake likes and so forth. Thoughts from other people – has this been happening in other countries?

  • KMCS1031

    Is there any research about who these friends of fans are? I’ve looked through the list of people who liked or shared a promoted post and a lot of them look like dummy accounts. Although the numbers were great, I was very disappointed because I know they aren’t exactly accurate.

  • http://www.facebook.com/kjimenez14 Kimberly Ann Jimenez

    Such great information and valuable content. I’ve tried promoted posts and have had great success. Thanks so much for sharing your insight, I’m definitely going to apply your advice in the future!

  • http://twitter.com/tonyparkin67 †ony PΔrkin▼

    Great article and strong rationale. However, on a recent promoted post for my company the reach went through the roof but on investigating the data over half the audience was from Indonesia (I’m a UK based site with only 10 Likes in total from that country) – so feel cheated that Facebook have fulfilled their number but with the wrong audience. Any others having this problem?

  • 122

    122

  • Mikkel Pitzner

    Great insights. Think I will try this today. It will be interesting to see if I can reach as many with such a low spend. Of course I really should figure out what I should sell them ;0)

  • http://www.CoffeeNate.com/ Nate

    I believe you can target your promoted posts. When you use the post targeting feature (the little bullseye looking thing), you can direct your ad to specific demographics. When you promote these posts, the original post targeting is adhered to, giving you targeting capabilities.

  • http://twitter.com/ZebWelborn Zeb Welborn

    Facebook tells me that my promoted post would reach between 1.2k and 2.4k or something to that effect and it only reached 390 people. Any ideas on why that is and do I have any recourse?

  • Alison

    I just found your article and wondered if you had any advice. I put two posts on my business page two days ago. I opted to spend £7 on each post for all the ‘page likers’ and their friends. On one post I have so far spent £5.34 and reached 2058 people and on the other I have spent the same amount of money but only reached 299 people. I have 720 likers and can’t understand how the figures can be so different. I would at least expect the full 720 to get the post? Any advice? Thanks.

  • http://www.AmyPorterfield.com Amy Porterfield

    Hi, Alison. I am not surprised that not all 720 likers saw the post – no matter how many fans you have, I don’t think you can ever reach all of them. Frustrating, I know. But as for such huge differences in the promoted posts, that one has me stumped. I am going to ask @jonloomer:disqus to weigh in on this one – he’s the Promoted Post wizard in my book!

  • mitch

    can all pages promote posts i am running for my schools senate and want to promote posts but the button is not showing like it does on other 3 pages i manage

  • http://www.facebook.com/g.i.ivanov Georgi Ivanov

    Hey, my question is, when i Pause the promotion (for example i promote for $10 and pause it with $8 remaining, so i’ve spent $2) where do my $8 go and can i use them for another promotion?

  • Eric

    I have read that you have to choose the demographic WHEN you post (before you push the Post button…)

  • 友德

    same happened to me. My company a r t i f e s t o . cn (https://www.facebook.com/Artifesto?fref=ts) india/malaysia/KL…. our market is china

  • http://www.facebook.com/aileen.irias Aileen Hernandez Irias

    Thank you, Jon. This article was exactly what I was looking for.

  • http://www.facebook.com/DessertDiva1998 Teresa Dames Crawford

    This was such a big help!! I own a custom cake business that includes cake decorating supplies and classes. I just did my first promoted post for a class that is scheduled in May. Can’t wait to see if the promoted post results in additional students!!

  • crapat

    I have spent 300$ last 5 days and i got only 300 new page likes, about 150 promoted post likes, when i look to full statistic frequency is killing my ads i have low target and it repeats to users :(

  • Sjors

    First of all, thanks of course for this article.

    We’ve been doing some promoting lately, and a lot of the people reached are from Bulgaria. Our production company is located here, but the audience we’d like to reach is across Europe & North America. We find it strange that our reach mostly stays within Bulgaria and doesn’t go to the rest. Is this due to the ip adres that it is being sent from or… ? We did a promotion once to target within bulgaria, but never since. Could this be it? I’ve been looking for answers within facebook and on internet, but haven’t found any (of course)

  • D

    Hi! What can you do, when a promoted post is live on facebook, but is not approved? can you redo a new one with the left over budget? or you will lose your bugget?